Skip to main content

making faces :: product review [morgana cryptoria]

plumeria
it's long been a source of irritation for me that with all the cosmetics on the market, there is really such a limited range of shades available from brands with high quality. usually, around halloween, you can find an assortment of blacks, silvers and whites, usually bog-standard drug or dollar store crap that's meant chiefly as a party joke. i tried manic panic's range of lipsticks, but i found them incredibly dry and tough to work with [and even they've drastically cut down their range of colours in the years since i tried them]. years back, mac had daring shades mixed in with their permanent range of shades, but that's been culled down in the name of inventory reduction. which means that those of us who would really like to see something outside the norm and who still want a quality product have been kind of stuck.

plumeria
plumeria
i can't quite remember how i came across morgana cryptoria, but i think it was just one of those internet coincidences, the end result of following one link after another until i ended up there. although the goth-inspired name made me think that the company was probably just another home operation peddling loose eye shadows, the glowing reviews their lipsticks received on line made me curious. most indie operations are not renown for their lip products, since those can be very difficult to make. and when i saw the daring and nuanced shades that they had available, i couldn't help but be curious.



i ended up ordering two of their lipsticks and a lip balm to give them a try. ordering is super-easy over their web site and you can pay through pay pal, which i appreciate. while delivery is understandably not as fast as a major company like mac or nordstrom's, shipping times are clearly stated on the web site and they honour those. i got notifications both when my order was processed and when it was shipped, so the whole experience felt very professional.

gargoyle's glance
i'm pleased to report that the quality of the lipsticks is excellent- on par with much larger makeup companies with more resources at their disposal. the shades go on smoothly and quite sheer- they need to be layered to be built up to full effect. however, the formula itself is so light that layering does not feel heavy on the lips at all. even when i applied a few layers of product, it felt like i wasn't wearing anything at all. the application is very even and while i wouldn't characterise them as moist, there is no drag or pull on the lips. whether worn as a single layer or built up, there is no patchiness, even when applied directly from the tube. [i haven't tried these with a lip brush yet, because i haven't had to.]

after a few hours, i did find that my lips felt a little dry, but they didn't show it. the colour lasted several hours on me without significant fading [unless i ate] and did not settle into lip lines or wear unevenly.

the lip balm is a lovely, soft texture, remarkably pigmented and not at all heavy. although i don't know that it would impart any long-term moisture to the lips, it's a great alternative for days when you may be feeling the effects of cooling temperatures and comes in an excellent range of shades.

gargoyle's glance
gargoyle's glance
as for the colours themselves, they are exactly the sort of offbeat shades i've been searching for. plumeria is a a plum-coloured base with a blue-turquoise sheen. depending on how the light strikes, you can see either more of the base or more of the sheen, meaning that it can pass for fairly conservative but with a bit of a kick. i think that this would be perfectly appropriate for office wear, since it doesn't call attention to itself, but it's still distinctive.

gargoyle's glance is a gunmetal grey base with what looks like a cool pink-lavender shimmer. this is a more noticeably different colour, although it can still be applied lightly to dampen the overall effect. it's a great modern, edgy shade a different take on the more dramatic black lip, something that requires less maintenance overall. it's neutral enough that i think it could work on a variety of skin tones.

spellcaster lip balm
the lip balm i got was spellcaster, a medium purple with a pronounced blue sheen. as i said, the balm shades are very pigmented and really function as a slightly softened lipstick shade. i found that my natural lip colour came through a little more with these than with the lipsticks, but the overall colour was very much true to how it looked in the tube. being a balm, it would be easy to apply with a light hand or by dabbing it on the lips for a subtle effect.

morgana cryptoria's lip products are vegan, thus offering an option to a group who often have trouble finding cosmetic alternatives. the shade range for lipsticks, balms and their new glosses is quite broad- it includes not only offbeat, unusual shades, but also reds, corals and pinks. lipsticks are $12usd each and balms are $7. since you can pay via pay pal, there is no issue with currency exchange- you pay the same no matter where you order from. you can also buy a membership, which allows you to get discounted prices and gives you access to shades not made available to the general public. excellent value for money and the best alternative i've found if you're looking for something a little off the beaten cosmetic path.

available at www.morganacryptoria.com



Comments

Zuzu*s Petals said…
I realize this post is older, but I just wanted to say that you have such beautifully-shaped lips. My thin upper lip just fainted. :^)
Kate MacDonald said…
Thank you so much!

as long as you're here, why not read more?

white trash

yes, my lovelies, i have returned from the dead, at least for the time it takes me to write this post. this is not just another piece of observational drivel about how i haven't been taking care of the blog lately, although i clearly haven't. on that front, though, the principal cause of my absence has actually been due to me trying to get another, somewhat related project, off the ground. unfortunately, that project has met with some frustrating delays which means that anyone who follows this blog [perhaps there are still a few of you who haven't entirely given up] would understandably be left with the impression that i'd simply forsaken more like space to marvel at the complexity of my own belly button lint. [it's possible you had that impression even before i disappeared.]

ok, enough with that. i have a subject i wanted to discuss with you, in the sense that i will want and encourage you to respond with questions, concerns and criticism in the comments or by em…

i'm definitely someone altogether different

about a hundred years ago, i remember having a partner who told me that, rather than writing the sort of ambiance-oriented crap [he didn't say crap, i'm saying it] that i was naturally driven to write, i should just compose something like the harry potter books. this wasn't out of any sense of challenging me to do new things but because of the desperate hope that my love of writing could be parlayed into something profitable.

my reaction at the time was "i just can't". and that was honestly how i felt because i didn't believe that that kind of story was in me. for the record, i still don't think that anything like the potter-hogwarts universe is in me. i'm not a fan of fantasy literature generally speaking and i feel like there's a richer experience to be examined in looking at our experience as regular humans being part of the rational, limited, everyday world and at the same time being able to feel connected to something that, for lack of a…

making faces :: a lip for all seasons [summer edition]

this may seem like an odd time to think about summer, but not to think about coolness. it can be hard to wrap your head around the idea that summer is considered "cool" in colour analysis terms and, in my opinion, reads as the coolest of the cool, because everything in it is touched with the same chilly grey. winter may have the coldest colours, but its palette is so vivid that it distracts the eye. everything in summer is fresh and misty, like the morning sky before the sun breaks through. in my original post on the season, i compared it to monet's paintings of waterlilies at his garden in giverny and, if i do say so, i think that's an apt characterisation.

finding lip colours touched with summer grey and blue is, as you might expect, kind of tricky. the cosmetic world seems obsessed with bringing warmth, which doesn't recognise that some complexions don't support it well. [also, different complexions support different kinds of warmth, but that's another…